Inherited property
We inherited a property together and can't agree on what to do with it. Now what?
Some of you want to sell, some of you don't want the tax bill. How co-owned inherited property works, what California's partition law provides, and the questions to take to your CPA and attorney.
An educational overview, not advice. Read the disclosures. They matter.
The short answer, before the detail
You and your co-heirs may not have to agree on as much as the argument suggests. If the property is held directly, the decision you most need to make together may be whether to sell. After a sale, each of you may be able to make a separate choice about your own share: take the cash and pay the tax, exchange into a property you choose, or exchange into a Delaware Statutory Trust, an investment with real risks that are set out below. Whether separate choices are open to your family is a question for your CPA.
That depends on how the property is owned, and checking that comes first. If a co-owner will not sell, California's partition law gives the co-owners who did not ask for a court-ordered sale the chance to buy out the ones who did, at a value the court determines.
Why "some want to sell, some don't want the tax" may not be a real deadlock
Here is one way this argument can sound. One sibling needs the money and wants to sell now. Another hears "sell" and thinks "huge tax bill," so they dig in. A third just wants everyone to stop fighting.
Everyone in that room may be assuming the family has to end up in the same place: everybody cashes out, or everybody keeps the building. That assumption is what creates the deadlock.
... The family is arguing about the destination. The only thing it has to agree on is the departure. ...
When the property is held directly, each of you owns a fractional interest in it, and that is the starting point for each share going in a different direction after a sale. The sibling who wants cash can take cash. The sibling who does not want a tax bill may, in the right circumstances, defer it with a 1031 exchange; an exchange defers the gain, it does not eliminate it.
That matters for more than taxes. Every other route through this problem, buying each other out, going to court, or one sibling pressuring another into a structure they did not choose, costs something between the people involved. Separate choices after a sale can avoid some of that.
Before anything else: how is the property actually held?
Everything above depends on this question, which is why it comes before the options.
Held directly by all of you as co-owners. When heirs each hold a share of the property in their own names, as tenants in common, each person owns a fractional interest in the real estate itself. The IRS has said that mere co-ownership of rental property that is maintained, kept in repair and rented out "does not constitute a separate entity for federal tax purposes." That is the starting point for each co-owner making a separate choice about their own share, and your CPA should confirm that it applies to your family.
You may run into a list of conditions from that same IRS document, presented as the test for whether co-owners can each do their own exchange. The document itself says those conditions are guidelines for requesting an IRS ruling and "are not intended to be substantive rules and are not to be used for audit purposes."
That does not mean anything goes. Co-owners who carry on a trade, business or venture together and divide the profits may create a separate entity for federal tax purposes, and that changes the answer. How you have actually been operating matters, and your CPA is the one to judge it.
Held in a partnership or a multi-member LLC. This is where "we'll each do our own exchange" runs into trouble. If your parent's property sits inside a partnership (including an LLC with more than one owner that is taxed as a partnership), what passes on a partner's death is an interest in the partnership. Under the federal regulation, interests in a partnership are not real property for a 1031 exchange. The regulation makes one exception, for a partnership that has a valid election in effect under section 761(a) of the tax code; whether that could apply is a question for your CPA. That is why separate exchanges by each heir may not be available when a partnership holds the building.
Some families ask whether ownership can be restructured before a sale so that co-owners can go separate ways. Whether anything like that can work in your case depends on the facts and on the timing. That work belongs to your CPA and your attorney, not to a web page, and the time to ask is before anything is listed.
Still in your parent's trust or estate. If the property has not yet been distributed to you, ask the trust or estate attorney whose name will be on title on the day it sells, and what that means for each of you making a separate choice. It is worth asking before anyone signs a listing agreement.
The bright line: anything other than direct co-ownership means call a CPA or attorney first
If title sits in a partnership, an LLC with more than one owner, a corporation, or a trust or estate that has not distributed yet, stop and bring in a CPA or tax attorney before the family makes any decision, including the decision to sell. We wrote about why ownership structure changes the tax answer for heirs in more detail in inherited a California rental you don't want?
If you need a referral, ask us.
Get connected with the right CPA or attorney for your situation
Run the number before anyone argues
The sibling refusing to sell "because of the taxes" may be defending against a number nobody has calculated.
When you inherit property, your income-tax basis generally resets to the property's fair market value on the date of death. The appreciation that built up over your parent's decades of ownership can drop out of the taxable gain. If the property sells at a price near that date-of-death value, the gain may be small.
So the starting point is two numbers: what the property was worth on the date of death, and what it is worth today. The gap between them, not the price your parent paid in 1985, is roughly the gain on the table. Recapture on any depreciation taken since the inheritance gets added on top.
Our California tax calculator gives an educational estimate of the tax on a sale from figures you enter, starting from the original purchase price. It has no input for a date-of-death value or a step-up, so it does not apply one.
Sometimes the number changes the conversation: the tax may turn out to be smaller than anyone expected.
What each choice looks like for one sibling, not for the whole family
If the property is held directly and the family agrees to sell, each of you may be able to choose your own door with your own share, once your CPA has confirmed it. Here is what each one looks like.
Take the cash and pay the tax
It fits when you want the money, your share of the gain is modest, or you simply do not want to own real estate.
What it costs. Tax on your share of the gain since the date of death, plus recapture on any depreciation taken since. California's 2025 income tax rates run from 1% to 12.3%, plus a 1.0% Behavioral Health Services Tax on taxable income above $1,000,000, for a top rate of 13.3%. California real estate withholding, reported on FTB Form 593, can apply to the sale: generally 3.33% of the sale price or 12.3% of the gain, under the form's withholding rules.
The honest downside. You are out of real estate, and any rental income stops. For a sibling who needs the money, that is not a downside at all. Taking the cash on purpose is a legitimate answer.
Exchange your share into a property you choose
It fits when you want to stay in real estate, just not in this building, and you are willing to be a landlord somewhere else.
What it requires. A 1031 exchange runs on fixed deadlines. Replacement property must be identified within 45 days of the sale. The exchange must close within 180 days of the sale, or by the due date of your tax return for the year of the sale, including extensions, if that comes first. Property identified or received outside those deadlines is treated as property that is not like-kind, and gain on the sale can then be taxed.
If you actually or constructively receive the full sale proceeds before you receive the replacement property, the regulation treats the transaction as a sale, not a deferred exchange. The regulation offers four safe harbors that address this, and a qualified intermediary is one of them. To use one, the regulation requires your rights in the sale contract to be assigned to the intermediary, with all parties notified in writing, on or before the date the property is transferred. In a family sale, that means each sibling who wants to exchange needs their own arrangement in place before the sale closes.
The honest downside. You traded a rental you did not choose for one you did, and you still have to run it. The replacement property carries its own investment risks. The exchange defers the gain; it does not eliminate it. The replacement property takes over the old property's basis, with the statute's adjustments, so the deferred gain is taxed when you later sell in a taxable sale, and depreciation recapture can come due then as well. If the replacement needs a loan, we wrote about financing in did financing kill your deal?
Exchange your share into a Delaware Statutory Trust
It fits when there is a real gain worth deferring, you want to stay invested in real estate, and you do not want to manage a property again.
A Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) holds real estate, and investors own fractional interests in it. An interest in a DST can serve as replacement property in a 1031 exchange when the trust is structured as the IRS's ruling on DSTs describes and the other requirements of a 1031 exchange are met.
The risks, with the same weight as the benefit.
- Not open to everyone. DST investments are generally offered through private placement offerings. In many cases, DST offerings are available only to investors who qualify as accredited investors.
- Illiquid, and the hold can be long. DST investments are generally illiquid and are not listed on a public exchange. Each offering sets its own terms; the trust the IRS ruled on was to last up to 10 years unless its property was sold sooner.
- No control. In the arrangement the IRS ruled on, the investors did not keep the right to manage and control the trust property, and the trust itself could not sell the property and buy another, renegotiate its lease or refinance without becoming a business entity, which with two or more owners is treated as a partnership and does not qualify.
- Risk to principal, and fees. DST investments involve investment risks, including the possible loss of principal. Investment objectives, risks, fees, expenses, tax considerations, and offering terms vary by investment and should be carefully reviewed before investing; any offer is made only through the offering's private placement memorandum and other offering documents.
- Not for everyone. DST investments are not suitable for all investors.
The honest downside. If the step-up already reduced most of your gain, a DST can tie up your money, possibly for years, to defer a tax that may be small. Whether that trade makes sense is a question for your CPA and advisor, and the number comes first.
Some of each
It fits when you want some money now and would rather defer tax on the rest.
You can exchange part of your share and take the remainder in cash. If the exchange otherwise qualifies, the gain taxed is capped at the amount of cash you take out, and it is taxed in the year of the sale.
The clock is running on all of you
A standoff can feel free. It has costs.
The step-up is fixed to the date of death. Appreciation after that date is not covered by the step-up, so it adds to the taxable gain on a later sale.
Property tax may have been reassessed. California's Proposition 19, operative for transfers on or after February 16, 2021, removed investment property from the old parent-to-child exclusion from property-tax reassessment. An inherited rental may be reassessed to market value.
A new recapture meter is running. If the property is still being rented and depreciated, that new depreciation can be recaptured later at a federal rate of up to 25%.
None of that means sell tomorrow. It means waiting has a cost, and each of you is paying a share of it. For more on Prop 19 and inherited rentals, see inherited a rental in California: Prop 19 and capital gains.
What if someone refuses to sell at all?
Sometimes a sibling will not sell under any circumstances. California law gives co-owners a court process for that case.
California's Partition of Real Property Act covers real property held as tenants in common where no agreement in a record, binding all the co-owners, governs how the property gets divided. It applies to partition lawsuits filed on or after January 1, 2023. You may see an older version of this law described as the "Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act." California adopted that act in 2021; a 2022 bill renamed the chapter, and its current definitions do not include "heirs property."
If a co-owner asks the court to order a sale, here is roughly what happens next.
First, the court sets the value. If all the co-owners have agreed on a value, or on a way to set it, the court adopts it. Otherwise the court generally orders an appraisal by a disinterested real estate appraiser licensed in California. The court sends notice of the appraised value to each party with a known address, a party may object within 30 days after that notice is sent, and the court holds a hearing, not sooner than 30 days after the notice, before it decides the value. At that hearing the court may also consider other evidence of value a party offers. There is one more path: if the court determines that the evidentiary value of an appraisal is outweighed by its cost, it determines the value itself after an evidentiary hearing, without an appraisal.
Then, the co-owners who did not ask for the sale get the chance to buy. Any co-owner who did not ask for the sale has 45 days after the court's notice to elect to buy out all the co-owners who did. The price for each share is the court-determined value of the whole property multiplied by that owner's fractional share. On a property valued at $1,500,000, a one-third share would be priced at $500,000. If one or more co-owners elect to buy, the court notifies all the parties of that once the 45-day window has closed. It then sets a date, not sooner than 60 days after that later notice was sent, by which the electing co-owners must pay their apportioned price into the court.
If every electing co-owner pays on time, the court reallocates the interests and pays out the money it holds. If nobody elects to buy, or no electing co-owner pays on time, the court goes on to resolve the partition case. If some electing co-owners pay on time and others do not, the court, on motion, tells the ones who paid what interest remains and its price; any of them may then buy all of the remaining interest by paying the entire price into the court within 20 days, and if none does, the court goes on to resolve the partition case.
What a buyout means for each person's taxes is a question for your CPA. For the family, it is a priced transaction at a court-determined value instead of an open-ended fight.
It is still a lawsuit, though, and it is the fallback rather than the plan. How it applies to your family, what happens when several co-owners elect to buy, and anything about a case already filed are questions for a California real estate attorney.
Questions to take to your CPA and attorney
These are the questions the answer turns on. The decisions are yours, made with your own CPA, attorney and advisor.
How is title held? Directly as co-owners, in a partnership or LLC, or still in a trust or estate. The deed, the trust documents and any entity tax return usually answer it.
What is really at stake in tax? The date-of-death value against today's value, plus any depreciation taken since the inheritance.
If the property is sold, what could each of you do with your own share, and what would each choice cost that person?
For anyone considering an exchange, what has to be in place before the sale closes?
If a co-owner will not sell, how would the Partition of Real Property Act apply to your family?
Each of you can also work through the decision tree separately.
Frequently asked
Can each of us do our own 1031 exchange with our share? It may be possible if you hold the property directly as co-owners and the arrangement is ordinary co-ownership rather than a business run together; your CPA should confirm it for your family. If an exchange uses a qualified intermediary, the regulation requires the arrangement to be in place on or before the date the property is transferred. If the property is in a partnership or a multi-member LLC, the answer changes; see the section on how title is held.
Our parent's property is in a family LLC. Can we still go separate ways? It is a question for a CPA and an attorney before anything is listed. Under the federal regulation, interests in a partnership, including an LLC taxed as a partnership, are not real property for a 1031 exchange, with one exception for a partnership that has a valid section 761(a) election in effect. Whether ownership can be restructured is a question for them too.
Are the IRS's co-ownership conditions the law? Not in the document's own words. Rev. Proc. 2002-22 says its guidelines are for requesting an advance ruling and "are not intended to be substantive rules."
Can I be forced to sell my share? A co-owner can ask a court to order a sale. Under California's Partition of Real Property Act, the co-owners who did not ask for the sale can then elect to buy out those who did, at the court-determined value. Talk to a California real estate attorney about your specific situation.
Is it better to just buy out my siblings privately? It can be, if everyone agrees on a price. An independent appraisal can keep the price from becoming its own argument, and your CPA can tell each of you what a buyout means for your taxes.
Estate Planning: Material prepared herein has been created for informational purposes only and should not be considered investment, tax, or legal advice or a recommendation. Information was obtained from sources believed to be reliable but was not verified for accuracy.
Estate planning involves complex legal and tax considerations that vary significantly based on individual circumstances and the laws of the applicable jurisdiction. Federal and state estate, gift, and generation-skipping transfer tax laws under the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) and applicable state statutes are subject to change, including scheduled sunset provisions that may alter exemption amounts and tax rates. The strategies discussed may not be suitable for all individuals, and their effectiveness depends on factors unique to each person's situation. Savvy Advisors Inc. does not provide legal advice or prepare legal documents. It is the responsibility of individuals to verify their own circumstances. Investors should consult their own qualified estate planning attorney, tax professional, and financial advisor before implementing any estate planning strategy.
Trust & Corporate Structures: Material prepared herein has been created for informational purposes only and should not be considered investment, tax, or legal advice or a recommendation to establish any particular trust, business entity, or corporate structure. Information was obtained from sources believed to be reliable but was not verified for accuracy.
The formation, administration, and taxation of trusts and corporate or business entities involve complex legal and tax considerations that vary based on individual circumstances, entity type, and the laws of the applicable jurisdiction. Federal tax treatment under the Internal Revenue Code (IRC), as well as applicable state laws governing entity formation and fiduciary obligations, are subject to change and to differing interpretation. The appropriateness of any trust or corporate structure depends on factors unique to each person's situation, and there is no guarantee that any anticipated legal protection or tax treatment will be realized. Savvy Advisors Inc. does not provide legal advice or prepare legal documents. It is the responsibility of individuals to verify their own taxation and legal obligations. Investors should consult their own qualified attorney, tax professional, and financial advisor before establishing or modifying any trust or corporate structure.
Important Disclosure Regarding Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) Investments
Delaware Statutory Trust ("DST") investments are generally offered through private placement offerings and are intended only for investors who satisfy the eligibility requirements established by the issuer and applicable securities laws. In many cases, DST offerings are available only to investors who qualify as accredited investors.
DST investments are not suitable for all investors. They are generally illiquid, are not listed on a public exchange, and involve investment risks, including the possible loss of principal. Investment objectives, risks, fees, expenses, tax considerations, and offering terms vary by investment and should be carefully reviewed before investing.
Nothing in this material constitutes an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any specific DST investment. Any offer may be made only by means of the applicable private placement memorandum and other offering documents. Investors should carefully review these materials and consult with their legal, tax, and financial advisors to determine whether a DST investment is appropriate in light of their individual circumstances.
1031 Exchange Disclosure: DST investments are often used as replacement property in connection with Section 1031 like-kind exchanges. Investors should consult with their qualified tax advisor regarding the tax consequences and eligibility requirements associated with a 1031 exchange. Neither this material nor the adviser provides legal or tax advice.
Why work with us, and how to judge anyone you'd trust with this
Many people selling an appreciated rental take advice from someone who earns more when they pick a particular door. That is the thing to watch for. Before you hand anyone a six-figure tax decision, ask four questions. Here is how we answer them.
-
How are you paid? We are fee-based. Our fee schedule is on our Fees page. We earn no commission on investments or DST placements. Our fee depends on what we manage for you. If you pay the tax, or exchange into a property you run yourself, there is no ongoing advisory fee on it. Want to check the numbers without us in the room? Our tax-on-sale calculator estimates the tax on a sale, and what a 1031 exchange or DST would defer, from the figures you enter; it doesn't recommend a path. Our decision tree walks through the options from your answers.
-
Are you a fiduciary? Yes. Advisory services run through Savvy Advisors, an SEC-registered investment advisor, which carries a legal duty to act in your interest, not merely to recommend something "suitable."
-
Do you actually specialize in this? I hold a Series 65 license; I have spent more than a decade working specifically on 1031 and DST transactions. Real estate is in my family, so the stakes here are not abstract to me. This is a narrow, technical corner of tax and real estate, and it is the corner I have chosen to know deeply. The California details in this article, the ones many advisors gloss over, are the daily work.
-
Will you give me the answer you can't sell? Yes. If the right move is to just pay the tax, we say so. There is no product we need to move. We are the sling, not a salesman with a quota.
Savvy is the platform behind the advice: a technology-forward, SEC-registered advisor built to take the friction out of the client-advisor relationship, with straightforward access to your information and broad access to most DST providers, so your options are not limited to a single sponsor's shelf.
If an advisor cannot answer those four cleanly, keep looking. If you want to walk your own numbers with someone who can, that is a conversation, not a sales pitch.
Sources
- Revenue Procedure 2002-22, Internal Revenue Service
- 26 CFR 1.1031(a)-3, definition of real property for section 1031
- Internal Revenue Code section 1014, basis of property acquired from a decedent
- Internal Revenue Code section 1031, exchange of real property held for productive use or investment
- Internal Revenue Code section 743, adjustment to basis of partnership property
- Internal Revenue Code section 1250, gain from dispositions of certain depreciable realty
- 26 CFR 1.1031(k)-1, treatment of deferred exchanges
- IRS Publication 544, Sales and Other Dispositions of Assets
- Revenue Ruling 2004-86, Internal Revenue Service
- 17 CFR 230.501, definition of accredited investor
- California Franchise Tax Board, 2025 California tax rate schedules
- California Franchise Tax Board, 2025 Form 593 instructions
- California State Board of Equalization, Proposition 19
- California Code of Civil Procedure sections 874.311 to 874.323, Partition of Real Property Act
- AB 633, Chapter 119, Statutes of 2021
- AB 2245, Chapter 82, Statutes of 2022
- Savvy Advisors, Inc. Form ADV Part 2A and Scott Eichler's Part 2B, SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure